05:00 PM

The Ethics of Protest Voting and Abstention Under Illegitimate Regimes
Colloquium

#Thursday Colloquium by Attila Mráz

In his lecture the philosopher explores the moral intuition that it is wrong to participate in elections when they serve to legitimize an illegitimate regime. His aim is to make sense of this idea of wrongful legitimization by electoral participation and assess its moral weight in the ethics of voting in electoral autocracies.

Attila Mráz argues that in such regimes, electoral participation can wrong fellow-citizens in two ways by maintaining an illusion of democratic legitimacy. First, this illusion may impede democratization. Second, illegitimate electoral regimes (and their ruling elite) commit a special wrong of subjection against their own citizens by maintaining an illusion of legitimacy. Voters are complicit in the latter wrong if they participate in certain ways in elections. However, it does not follow that they should always abstain.

Instead, to avoid or mitigate complicity, eligible voters should engage in context-specific kinds of protest voting and abstention, including sheer abstention, ballot-spoiling, or electoral boycott. Moreover, voters should vote for a viable regime-opposition if there is a reasonable chance of peaceful democratization by electorally overturning the autocratic regime. In other words, the moral case against legitimizing an illegitimate electoral regime by voting is strong but conditional.

This event is addressed to fellows and their tandem partners.